qtpieash3's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A quick read that I thoroughly enjoyed! Maybe not the best book to read after finally getting COVID, but a raw, real account from an ER doctor in the Bronx detailing the spring of 2020. I love the story behind this one - Dr. Meyer finds himself unable to be completely honest with his family and friends about how hard being on the front lines of COVID is, but is able to talk to his cousin Dan, a journalist, about it. This book is a look back at that COVID spring using those phone conversations, voicemails, texts, emails, and voice memos as the source data. The stories are hard to listen to at times - we all know how much our healthcare workers have been through, but hearing Dr. Meyer recount it is chilling - the fear, uncertainty, exhaustion, and horror come through loud and clear. My case was fortunately extremely mild (thank you science for vaccines, boosters, and continually evolving knowledge on how to treat COVID) but I remember distinctly how scary a potential COVID diagnosis was in 2020. Every cough, every tickle in the throat and you would wonder - this book reminds me of how far we've come.

I listened to the audiobook and flew through it.

katemsteller's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This is exactly what I’ve been looking for in terms of a covid memoir from a frontlines perspective - really well written and compelling.

thelaurablossom's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

a window into the emergency department of montfiore hospital in the bronx in march-may 2020. thoughtful, poignant, and also a barely contained sense of rage and overwhelm. mass graves in america in 2020? yes. how to preserve a patient's dignity in the face of the pandemic -- these are questions meyer & his cousin co-author tackle in this important memoir.

veronica_vazquez7737's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

It was good to remember how terrifying this illness was in the beginning. I didn’t find it as illuminating as Banana: the Fate of the Fruit That Changed the World .

jzoni's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A first-hand account of the early days of the pandemic in a Bronx hospital. So well written.

arabellafleetwood's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Good book, great personal account of dealing with the pandemic as a doctor. The battle of being at a loss to help when you are trying your best.

emmyjames's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark emotional hopeful informative inspiring reflective sad tense medium-paced

4.75

scwoodyard's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

It was a decent read. It was very disjointed, with no real structure to it. However seeing as this is more of a journal documenting the first major wave of COVID in the northeast, it kind of makes sense. It didn't seem to go through the rigorous process of editing for a cohesive structure. That would have made the narrative a bit better.

What I can appreciate about it is the honesty and vulnerability of the doctor as well as the fact that I got to read a primary source from an absolutely notable time in history.

novelvisits's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Rounded up from 3.75. Interesting, touching, but I was more moved by Voices from the Pandemic by Eli Saslow.

barefootmegz's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Like many healthcare workers, I have often turned to narratives to cope with my work, and these have been plentiful during the (COVID) pandemic. But eventually one reaches a point where you can no longer look into the mirror of your daily life – and I have reached that limit much sooner than I expected.

Every Minute Is A Day by Meyer (MD) and Koeppel is dedicated to the “many, many people [who] died alone, without their loved ones.” This is important: the express purpose of this book was “to honor and respect those this disease claimed.”

I cringed when I first considered my rating for Every Minute Is A Day. I did not exactly love Meyer’s memoir, but I do not doubt that it will find its audience of ardent readers.

With the advent of COVID literature, I have often found myself drawing parallels with books written about World War II. For as long as I have been a reader, WWII has been a favourite topic of authors and readers. Why is it that the world so loves a good Auschwitz novel?

Reading Every Minute Is A Day gave me some insight into that phenomenon. While WWII took place long enough ago that most readers alive today did not experience it personally; it occurred recently enough that the effects on our lives remain tangible.

Conversely, the world is still living COVID, and throughout Every Minute I have not been able to clear the term “too soon” from my mind. Meyer writes how “the rules kept changing” – and they continue to do so. In some ways, Every Minute feels like a tribute written too soon.

Does Meyer’s memoir achieve what it set out to do? I believe so. It may clear up much confusion for laypersons. I think it may provide peace when people think about their relatives, and how they could not be with them in their final moments. I hope that survivors will know not only that their healthcare workers cared, but how they cared. I hope they will know that the masks, the PPE, the difficulty communicating, were all as challenging for their doctors as for patients and relatives. That death weighed heavily on them, and that any perceived inadequacies were doubly perceived by healthcare workers themselves.

So much of the memoir should be relatable, but the authors actually detract from that by focussing largely on Montefiore – a hospital they are clearly, and rightfully, very proud of. But that singular focus leads to an atmosphere of “us, alone” – we alone were suffering. We alone were scrambling to make things work. That this is not the author’s intention is not the point – the impression that it creates, is.

What I miss most of all is growth, and hope. Every Minute depicts so well the despair. The confusion. The feelings of failure. But by the end of it all, I cannot see the growth I would have liked to see, and once more I venture that it comes down to timing. The author cannot depict that which is yet to come fully to fruition. Again, I do not think the time is right for THIS memoir. Soon, but not yet.

I received an advanced review copy of this book via Netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.